Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
19 comments
24 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/25/2008
Godfather all the way
on 3/19/2012
I gotta give it to The Godfather here.
on 7/6/2012
OMGS! Why these two. Ugh!
on 7/7/2012
Too easy.
I like the lord of the Rings very much
I'll go with Fellowship. I have a much higher appreciation for epics.
on 10/21/2012
The Fellowship of the Ring for me. It will always be in my top 5 films and I just love it dearly.
on 12/11/2012
Part II is also an epic...a mob epic.
on 2/3/2013
Two epic films. I'll choose Part 2.
Fellowship wins easily i dont like part II that much the original Godfather is amazing though.
on 4/22/2013
I can understand @MrAwesome245--I love Part 2 but yeah...Part 1 is far better IMO...Fellowship will remain my #1 film and I believe the only film to top it could only possibly be The Godfather
on 4/23/2013
The Godfather Part II is too fucking good.
on 6/25/2013
The Godfather, Part II beats LOTR in every department.
on 8/9/2013
Godfather 2
on 8/13/2013
Fellowship, to me, is the perfect film. The film that encompasses everything that film is capable of doing and does it right. The Godfather Part II is great, but it can't beat Fellowship.
I got Fellowship ahead of GF II....but damn....so close.
Fellowship is a great Movie, but no match for the Godfather II
Fellowship wins here, it's the best LotR film but it wouldn't win against the best Godfather film.
on 8/14/2013
Godfather 2. It haunts me more than Sauron ever could.
on 9/2/2013
Fellowship. It will always hold a special place in my heart.
on 3/8/2014
i gotta watch godfather 2 again...
on 3/11/2014
I reckon matchups like this is the reason Flickchart was established: Apple vs. Orange. The only thing they have in common are the fact that they are flawless. There's really no right or wrong answer here. This matchup simply shows what movie type of movie you prefer rather than how good or bad your movie taste is. As for me, if both these were on TV on a Saturday night, I'd likely watch FOTR.
LOTR just rewatch Godfather 2
on 3/12/2014
Godfather II takes it.
on 8/23/2014
I did not like Part II, first is better, I choose Fellowship instead.
on 8/24/2014
While I enjoy Godfather Part II, I'd still pick Fellowship over it any day.
on 11/20/2016
There are very few movies which beats fellowship of the ring, the godfather part 2 is NOT one of them
on 6/25/2018
LotR: Fellowship is far amazing moments a better enveloping great story fantasy than that Godfather II is.
on 7/12/2018
I agree with @Koroy, Godfather II ain't one of the films that beats Fellowship, I have to say LotR is one of he best films in all history.
on 8/20/2018
LotR.
on 9/29/2018
The Godfather Part II would've been all-time classic for me had if it weren't so needlessly bloated and gimmicky with the intrusive flashbacks. Fellowship of the Ring is a far better structured film with each scene flawlessly falling into the next and delivering one hell of an adventure that makes eagerly wait for the next in the process. For me, the Lord of the Rings trilogy as a whole is far better than The Godfather trilogy.
on 10/2/2018
The Godfather Part II is so much better that it makes my bowels flow thinking anyone would prefer watching LOTR over the Godfather films.
Lord of the Eings is far better of the greatest fantasy films ever, Godfather II is certainly never that simple for me...
on 7/19/2020
Lord of the Rings: Fellowship.
on 11/22/2020
godfather 1/2 >>> any LOTR
on 11/29/2020
The Godfather Part II has a much better story, better acting, and more emotional impact. GF2 and it's not even close.
on 2/11/2021
I'm gonna temporarily tie this discussion; I like Fellowship slightly more, as I love both films.
on 7/22/2021
There is no admiring that godfather calling it simple better in a whole entire way since the lord of the rings is far the biggest fantasy stories ever made
on 5/4/2022
The Fellowship of the Ring wins here
on 9/17/2022
The Godfather Part 2 wins this pretty handily. More powerful themes, more subtle and intelligent writing, more complex characters, better acting, better cinematography, better, editing, etc.
on 12/30/2022
Lord of the rings barely wins this
on 1/26/2023
Part 2 barely wins this.
Lord of the rings stomps here
As much as I love the Lord of the Rings trilogy, I have to give it to Godfather Part II
on 1/27/2023
Lord of the rings absolutely takes the nod, Godfather II ain’t that simple
on 5/22/2023
I love lord of the rings more, but I have to go with godfather
Lord of the rings is far better, Godfather 2 is overlong no good value as the first film
