Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
19 comments
20 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 5/28/2011
? seriously ?
on 2/20/2012
Both entertaining films but Im going with the second installation of the Godfather. Al Pacino is amazing in his role as Michael Corleone. PS: So is Eli Wallach as Tuco
on 3/21/2012
The Godfather still takes it out. Much more epic. Especially for a sequel.
on 10/10/2012
Part II for me. Not as close as it appears.
I always thought that The Good, The Bad, & The Ugly was a great epic western. Blondie, Tuco, and Angel Eyes all day.
on 10/16/2012
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
on 12/11/2012
On second glance, this is pretty tough. Gotta rewatch them now.
on 12/12/2012
Part II
on 2/13/2013
The Godfather 2, but this is close.
I'm gonna go with The Godfather II...but so damn close is right....
on 2/14/2013
Shit just got real my friends. The Godfather Part II wins it in my book, but barely.
on 6/29/2013
TGTBATU.
on 9/9/2013
Hmmm... GBU wins for a noise here.
on 9/15/2013
Godfather Part II. I enjoyed it more, and I also believe it's the better film.
on 9/27/2013
Godfather Part II. GBU is my favorite western though, it's so fantastic. But in the end, both Godfather films beat it for having more interesting characters and a better story.
on 1/17/2014
Crazy contest here. GBU for me.
GBU is a great film and top tier western but for my money I say The Godfather Part II is the better film. Godfather Part II has such intensity and depth in its story telling and characters. Its definitely one of the true classics in film.
on 2/17/2014
The Godfather Part II
It is actually Part II.. one of the best films in all
on 3/28/2014
If Godfather II were just the Vito Corleone parts it would surely win. That whole Cuba thing drops the bar just a little bit for me, every time I watch it.
on 6/23/2014
Wow, this is tough.
on 8/15/2014
The Good The Bad The Ugly for me
on 10/18/2014
If it was the first godfather i would go with that but I think The Good the Bad and the Ugly beats Part II
on 5/28/2018
I'm taking TGTBATU.
on 5/29/2018
I vote for the mobster epic part best sequel of all time.
The Good, The Bad & The Ugly is superior in every way. Story, acting, scale, music, direction, overall excitement. EVERYTHING.
The Godfather Part II may be the greatest movie ever made.
on 3/1/2019
The Godfather Part II wins this one, and not even close.
Yes, The Godfather Part II and no one should pretend that it is even close.
on 8/28/2019
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly has better music and great story.
on 3/12/2020
The Godfather Part II is the best movie of all time
Michael Corleone easily over Clint Eastwood
on 8/5/2020
The good, the bad and the ugly by far.
on 11/29/2020
The Godfather Part II has a better story and better acting. It's haunting ending cuts deeper than anything in The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly. GF2 wins this.
on 12/10/2020
The Godfather Part II is the more powerful film.
on 7/21/2021
The good the bad and the ugly is the far superior classic film of the 60s
on 4/21/2022
both are powerful movies, but GF2 is one of my fav films of all time
on 12/19/2022
The good the bad and the ugly is that great it is
on 4/10/2023
The Good The Bad and The Ugly win very Difficulty
on 6/7/2023
The good the bad and the ugly
on 7/11/2023
As excellent as The Good, the Bad and the Ugly is, The Godfather Part II is some of the best movies ever made
