Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
16 comments
13 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/16/2009
though one, but i go with the classic
on 2/3/2010
omg.
Id go with godfather- saving pvt. ryan has great visuals and its one of the most realistic war movies of its time, but in godfather, Marlon Brando definitely shows how he was one of the best actors ever.
on 4/12/2011
stumped(2)
on 7/20/2011
Saving Private Ryan made me cry. It's very rare a movie does that to me. VERY rare.
The Godfather is a classic, but Saving Private Ryan is one of my favorite movies.
Wow. I gotta go with Ryan. I'm not sure I can say why, or list any kind of reasoning. Saving Private Ryan had an impact on me like few movies can...
I few years ago I would've picked Saving Private Ryan, but I rewatched them both and I now remember why everyone got so hyped up about The Godfather. It's because it's amazing! The Godfather is the winner here.
on 9/2/2011
the hardest choice i have ever made. but im going godfather on this one.
I'm going with one of the best war films ever made.
on 2/4/2012
Were talking about The Godfather here
on 2/13/2012
Both great films, but The Godfather is legend.
on 3/8/2012
Gotta go with Saving Private Ryan only just.
on 9/14/2012
Can't believe Private Ryan is winning this. It's a great film but dude? Godfather!
Ill pick the best war movie ever over the second best gangster movie ( #1 is GoodFellas).
on 2/3/2013
Ryan is an absolutely moving film, so is Godfather. I just love gangsters more.
on 4/14/2013
I agree with PiccoloKing...What is so legendary and masterful about Private Ryan to take down The Godfather. Saving Private Ryan is amazing but The Godfather exceeds it by miles! I don't get it, anyways, its the Godfather, a no brainer for me
on 5/4/2013
i feel sorry for ryan.
on 9/9/2013
Saving Private Ryan. When looking at the Godfather films, only Part II could knock out Ryan, even with all the greatness of the original. It had an emotional impact on me more than anything, seeing how my father and war and all that. SPR.
on 10/24/2013
Saving Private Ryan wins this one for sure. The Godfather is a miserable gangster movie, I really had great expectations for The Godfather, but then it turned out to be a bad movie with both bad story and bad acting, and there was not any action nor excitement, not even at the shooting scenes, and Godfather was TOO boring and lengthy. Godfather can only be discouraged. While Saving Private Ryan has much excitement, better acting, better music, and much better action scenes. Saving Private Ryan wins here at any day.
on 10/25/2013
Y'know, I think I like SPR better.
on 4/16/2014
The Godfather
Saving Private Ryan
on 4/25/2014
It's the friggin godfather. Movie of all movies
Both movies have so many strong performances and Tom Hanks is my favorite actor of all time but I have to side with The Godfather.
This is pretty impressive. I'll side with Saving Private Ryan I think. I love both movies though so it's tough to pick.
on 8/26/2015
I'll take Ryan here. More entertaining. GodFather Part 2...maybe not.
on 8/27/2015
I love godfather love it but it drags on some parts.Saving pvt. Ryan on the other hand is one of my all time favourite movie and is entertaining as a whole package.Saving pvt. Ryan for the victory.Granted Even Tom Hanks has nothing on Marlon brando and Al pacino when they are in form
on 5/10/2017
FUCK. One of the hardest match-ups
on 6/3/2019
Godfather easily
on 7/19/2020
Saving Private Ryan is one of the best in every way.
on 11/16/2020
saving private ryan is pretty bad my dudes
on 4/23/2023
Saving Private Ryan is a really good movie and all but it's THE GODFATHER. Suprised that this is even close.