Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
8 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/2/2009
Iron Giant easily.
on 11/17/2009
Two Brad Bird masterpieces, but I love the Incredibles, so there.
on 5/27/2010
"Iron Giant" surprised me a bit more; but the superhero fan in me says I have to vote for "The Incredibles."
on 5/28/2010
The Inrcredibles is great, and all, but, in this case, I have to choose the movie that endeared me to a character voiced by Vin Diesel, of all people.
on 7/13/2010
Nevermind. I take that back. The Incredibles just gets better with each viewing.
on 9/4/2010
One word: "Su-per-man." Gets me every time....
on 11/28/2010
God, these movies are both almost perfect. Brad Bird...what a guy! I think Iron Giant has the edge because of a smidge more creativity and whimsy, and boy did this film make me cry.
on 8/1/2011
Both are fantastic, but I too am going with Iron Giant.
on 8/2/2011
Both are excellent movies - I have to go with Iron Giant.
on 8/9/2011
Loved The Iron Giant the first time I saw it, and I'm still in love with it. I forgot most of the Incredibles despite it being a very great film. The Giant wins.
on 8/8/2012
The Incredibles is great and I want a sequel, but the Iron Giant is one of my favorite movies.
on 8/31/2012
The Iron Giant is a magical experience- almost a masterpiece. The Incredibles, however, is a hilarious and moving satire on the superhero genre. While The Iron Giant is more emotionally strong, The Incredibles is more fun. Still, these two surprisingly adult animated films both deserve a viewing (heck, they deserve multiple viewings) and they both exist as further proof of Brad Bird's genius.
on 12/31/2012
Two great ones from Brad Bird, but The Incredibles wins.
on 2/13/2013
iron giant is a lost treasure.But the incredibles is to unforgettable it wins.
on 5/12/2013
Don't get me wrong, The Iron Giant is an excellent movie. I just think that The Incredibles is slightly better. Brad Bird is marvelous at directing action...
on 1/21/2014
Brad Bird time! "The Iron Giant" asks a question which I can never seem to find the answer to. How can a film, which is virtually a remake of another classic earn the status of a classic? Yet, in all the cases in which this is evident ("Roman Holiday", "A Fistful of Dollars", "The Iron Giant"), I do enjoy each film greatly. This matchup is especially difficult. Perhaps Pixar wins.
on 5/30/2015
For me, it's also a very close call, but Incredibles' amazing action sequences and cool villain, along with an excellent cliff-hanger ending, beat out Iron Giant. "Su-per-man" keeps on coming back to haunt me and want me to choose Giant, though.
on 9/3/2015
Iron Giant has more heart. So much heart in fact that it nearly rivals the Toy Story trilogy. Incredibles is very fun. This is an extremely close match-up.
on 3/15/2016
The Iron Giant
on 4/7/2018
The Iron Giant without a doubt.
on 2/13/2019
Iron Giant is good,but I felt more when I watched Incredibles.
