The Departed vs. Gangs of New York



on 1/13/2010

Gangs has the amazing Daniel Day-Lewis, but it's hampered by lame performances from DiCaprio and Diaz. In The Departed DiCaprio actually gives a great performance along with the rest of the cast, and the film is more tension-filled than almost anything else out there.

on 1/15/2010

^^ Couldn't agree more. For me, somewhere between 2002 and 2006 is when DiCaprio hit his stride and really became a first class actor and a great leading man. It hadn't happened yet in Gangs, and I think he and Diaz are pretty bad. The brilliance of Day-Lewis aside, The Departed also had the smarter, tighter story. The film is intricately plotted and is really one of Scorsese's best works.

on 3/5/2010

I don't remember DiCaprio being bad in Gangs. I do remember Day-Lewis being fantastic, but I also remember not caring for the overall movie, and Diaz was out of place. However, I love every inch of The Departed. Great movie.

on 3/5/2010

And, it's the only Scorsese film I've seen that I can say that about.

on 3/1/2012

Yeah, maybe DiCaprio wasn't bad in Gangs of New York, just out of his league when on the same screen as Daniel Day-Lewis. I'll stand by my original Cameron Diaz criticism, though.

on 6/3/2013

I love Gangs of New York, but The Departed is my favorite Scorsese film.

on 6/3/2013

The Departed is too much for even The Butcher....

on 5/26/2014

Departed -in the closes margin love both but Departed is so slick and engaging.