Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
8 comments
7 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/15/2009
I don't like Spider Man 2 as much as most. I love Elf though.
on 10/15/2011
Elf is just a more fun movie. The action in spider man 2 is great as is the whole movie but Elf is just such a great movie.
Spiderman 2 is one of the best superhero movies ever, and elf is cute. Spiderman 2 wins.
Elf is horrible. What do people see in it? Truly one of the most grating movie experiences that I have endured.
on 7/27/2013
Elf is hilarious. But Spider-Man 2 is quite possibly the best superhero movie ever made. Gotta go with Spidey 2.
I'll also go Spidey....but I'm sad to say that I'm not a huge fan of either....
Elf is cute, and often quite funny. It's still about a half a notch below Spider-Man 2, however.
on 5/20/2014
Spider-Man is my favourite superhero and this film is so entertaining for me and it also very nostalgic. I used to watch it all the time as a kid. I do prefer the original Tobey Maguire one though. Elf is quite a bad movie and shouldn't be loved.
Spidey easily
on 6/25/2014
Definitely did not expect this to be a contentious match-up. Going with Elf because, as much as I like Spider-Man 2, I'll take Will Ferrell and Zooey Deschanel over Tobey Maguire and Kirsten Dunst.
on 6/26/2014
Spider-Man 2 is one of the greatest comic book movies ever made and is also among some of my favorite movies so it easily wins. Elf is a movie that I got tired of really fast growing up even though a lot of people insisted it was a "holiday classic".
on 8/31/2016
I'm gonna take Elf. Spider-Man 2 is the shiz but I love Elf too much.
on 9/3/2016
Elf! It's hilarious!
on 8/7/2020
They’re both great but Elf is just the perfect Christmas movie. It’s just so much fun.
on 12/16/2020
Elf is original and hilarious, rather than just another superhero flick, so it wins here.
on 11/9/2021
Yes, Elf wins here for me
Sorry Elf but Spider-Man 2 for me.
