Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
7 comments
12 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/13/2012
Modern classics that accumulated a cult following soon after their releases. Fight Club stands tall.
Vote against Fight Club? I'm afraid I can't do that, Dave.
The movie without the giant space fetus.
on 4/1/2013
Sigh... It's a travesty for anyone to pick Fight Club over 2001.
on 4/2/2013
Obv. Fight club. Did 2000 or whatever have a cool computer generated apartment explosion or a rockin' soundtrack? YOLO YOLO YOLO
Love the sarcasm... I think. :-/
on 4/25/2013
Neither in my favourites, but still both excellent films. As I have said before, 2001 feels more sterile than a maternity clinic despite it's technical brilliance, and I don't feel like I have a reason to care about the origins of life, the universe and everything. There are documentaries which have done a much better job at that. Fight Club social commentary may not be especially significant to me as I feel no oppression of my masculinity, but I do enjoy David Fincher's visual style and the dry humour is top notch. Fight Club wins here, but barely.
on 6/23/2013
Fight Club continues to stand strong.
on 7/11/2013
Fight Club is fantastic, 2001 is not.
Agree with JC13. Fight Club is funny, smart and intriguing. Everything about the film makes sense and the film continue to entertain. It doesn't have 3 minutes of black screen to open the film. That's how you can decide whether a film is screwed or not.
on 11/7/2013
I used to think 2001 was good for what it was but after I saw it again it was much easier to watch and enjoy. I'll go with 2001.
on 2/15/2014
Both are in my top 20, but I liked Fight Club more.
on 6/19/2014
2001 i simply like it more!
on 10/16/2014
2001.
Tw00ne. Wow, I could be a graphic designer for a bunch of hipster minimalist T-shirts!
2001, the one that wasn't entirely built on a gimmick
on 6/2/2018
Tyler Durden is still perfect but it can't top the brilliance of 2001.
on 6/3/2018
2001 is probably the most artistic and complex movie ever! Fight Club... meh
Fight Club it is.
