Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
12 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/23/2009
I find this one extremely difficult for some reason.
on 11/17/2009
AAARRRRGGGGG! How canthey force me to pick between Donnie Darko and Fight Club!? They're tied for my top spot just about...
on 12/3/2009
I love them too much
on 12/5/2009
Fight Club is good for sure, but Donnie Darko scores higher for me
on 1/12/2010
Both have rewatchability in their favorite. That said, I find Donnie Darko to hold up better upon repeat viewings than Fight Club by a smidge.
on 1/28/2010
In 2002, I would've found this more difficult. DD is good, but hasn't held up as well as FC.
on 2/7/2010
wow, this one's a hard choice
on 2/13/2010
Impossible choice but Donnie Darko wins for it's amazing soundtrack
on 3/3/2010
Wow! the most comments I've seen yet about a matchup. I love both, but Fight Club has the edge because of Fincher, the actors and quotability. But just barely.
on 7/23/2010
Donnie Darko for sure.
on 3/10/2011
Fight Club is so much better than Donnie Darko. No contest.
on 1/4/2013
2 of my favourite movies ! Donnie Darko is so great I have to give it
on 5/12/2013
I reckon Donnie Darko, favourite film of all time I think.
on 8/4/2013
Donnie Darko does have a great soundtrack, better than Fight Club's. I wasn't spoiled of the ending to Donnie Darko, so it wins. If I wasn't spoiled of the twist to Fight Club, then I would've liked it a lot more. I still really like it but Donnie wins because of the style, that I loved.
on 4/28/2014
Donnie Darko is on a whole other level may not be a fun to watch as fjgh club but that why I love it! it takes you down a rabbit hole a changes you as a person its so dark and moody with a brain hurt that feels so good after you watch it.
on 5/28/2015
I think Donnie Darko.
on 5/29/2015
Both really stick with you after you watch them. Donnie Darko
on 5/31/2015
This is extremely close but I think I'll go with Fight Club... just barely
on 7/13/2015
WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!?!? FIGHT CLUB BY FUCKING LIGHTYEARS HOLY SHIT! FUCK THIS DONNIE DARKO TEEN CULT SHIT!!!
on 9/6/2015
Donnie Darko is the teen angst film for emo shitheads.
on 8/9/2017
Fight Club
on 12/1/2019
Fight club is solid overrated, Donnie Darko is a film that considers great of rewatched.
Fight Club in first round.
on 3/18/2023
Imma go with Fight Club just for personal preference. BOTH VALID PICKS.
