The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance vs. Mr. Smith Goes to Washington



Two great films with great performances from Jimmy Stewart. Slight edge goes to Mr Smith.

this is why Jimmy Stewart is one of my Favorite actors-Mr.Smith is great outstanding Performance and story and While Liberty Valance is one of the best westerns ever Mr.Smith Goes To Washington is original and masterful.not an easy win but it does.

Jimmy Stewart is fantastic in both,but MWSLV wins.

Better direction, more actors, and an ending that actually follows up the cimax. Edge goes to "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance"

Mr. Smith all day....

God I really love both but Liberty takes it.

Liberty Valance for me.

Liberty Valance over Mr. Smith but two awesome classics.

Both are top 100 for sure. For much i love Mr. Smith, the edge goes to Liberty Valance!

Give me Liberty or give me death.

Mr. Smith Goes to Washington wins for me.

Two political films featuring great performances by James Stewart. Mr Smith has Frank Capra's direction, a charming script and it's also really inspiring so it gets the win!

I was very impressed with both movies, but Mr. Smith Goes to Washington left a more emotional impact on me.