The Thing vs. Sleepy Hollow



on 9/7/2010

This one is tough...headless horseman or bodiless alien? Depp or Russell? Colonial New England or the Antarctic? I'll take Burton's evil grin of a movie for now, but who knows when I'll get a hankerin' for Carpenter's creepy, isolated horror gem.

on 9/20/2013

The Thing.

on 9/20/2013

The Thing wins. It's so atmospheric,dark,intense and suspenseful. Truly a horror masterpiece.

on Jan 18

The Thing trumps most films. Wins this matchup EASILY.