Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
14 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 9/19/2009
Oh heck. Well, you know, Hellboy is arguably more FUN to watch, and is probably more likely to get repeat viewings from me, but damn, if Pan's Labyrinth wasn't a piece of genius. This is really hard. Labyrinth is a better movie, really, I suppose.
on 12/25/2009
Hellboy more fun to watch? Uh, no. Hellboy II, maybe. But not Hellboy. Pan's Labyrinth has both style and substance. Hellboy is a little lacking in both. Pan's Labyrinth, without a moment's hesitation.
on 12/30/2009
I loved both these movies, but Pan's Labyrinth was on a whole other level. Now that I think about it, I haven't seen Hellboy 2. Gotta fix that.
on 1/17/2010
Hellboy was a relatively unparalleled disappointment for me. I'd only seen one other film of Guillermo del Toro's at the time, which just so happened to be Pan's Labyrinth, and to call it a favorite would be an understatement, as it came to rest at second place all-time on my list. By comparison, Hellboy seemed watered down. If it were not for Hellboy II: The Golden Army and The Devil's Backbone, I'd've started to think of Pan's Labyrinth as some sort of wondrous anomaly. Luckily, it's not.
on 4/2/2010
I really liked Pan's,but I love Hellboy. so...
on 7/19/2010
Del Toro, the man is a certified genius. Hellboy is good, but Pan's Labyrinth is the pinnacle of his work so far.
on 8/4/2010
I like both of these movies, but I have to give the nod to Pan's Labyrinth for the story it tells. The visuals on both films are fantastic. . .
on 3/20/2012
Hellboy I can watch over and over again, but the story in Pan's Labryinth was phenomenal. Tough choice, but I Pan.
on 12/8/2013
Helloy was cool and fun but feels like a marvel movie where Pan felt fresh and original.Pans Labyrith wins
I enjoyed Hellboy, but Labyrinth is one of the greatest films I've ever seen, easily Del Toro's opus.
on 1/8/2014
Hellboy could been the better hero but it mostly can do of Pan's Labyrinth saw one of interest impressive of can do on to that
on 5/24/2015
Hellboy takes it easily, next to all the way. Toro's masterpiece by far.
on 1/9/2016
I STILL have not revisited Pan. But I vote for it with less hesitation these days.
on 1/29/2016
Pan's Labyrinth is brilliant in every manner. The way in which del Toro used the fantasy world as a way of contrasting the harshness of the real world made for one of the most emotionally driven films of the last decade! Hellboy is.....okay
on 4/6/2018
Pan's Labyrinth is a pure stroke of genius. As much as I like Hellboy, Pan's Labyrinth takes this in a landslide.
on 6/1/2020
Please don't make me choose
on 6/2/2020
Pan's Labyrinth is the superior film.
on Feb 12
I have never been able to get into the first Hellboy (although I love 2). Pan's Labyrinth takes an easy W.
