Sign In Now ►
or Create A New Account ►
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
The two best of the Elm Street movies, and both great in entirely different ways. Gotta go with the original, but that's no insult to NEW NIGHTMARE, a fantastic flicker in its own right.
Not easy, because both are great and the best of the Nightmare movies
Both are greats of the series. The original is the best. The feel of it can never beat any of the other movies.
New Nightmare is definitely one of the better sequels, but the original is still at the very top of the bunch and always will be.
Both are two of the series best. New Nightmare is the best sequel, but the original will always be the best film.
The Original, although WCNN was freaking brilliant.
I enjoyed New Nightmare, but I can't go against the original...
Still gotta go with the original it introduced Freddy and had the better kills and story Man I love the genius of New Nightmare but still The Original wins.
Man, New Nightmare is brilliant! But I'll take the original here.
The original takes it. Love New Nightmare and Dream Warriors as well.