Spider-Man 3 vs. Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest



too much cgi, too convoluted. These both sucked.

Good gracious both of these movies are miserable. I'm not sure which one is worse.

A reminder: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rz4h0AT5iY vs. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=blEGQiSNYvs

Spider man 3 sullied an amazing franchise. Dead Man's Chest hurt a fun summer distraction, so it's crime is much less.

I liked the Pirates sequels more than most people did. Yes it got kind of convoluted and I don't like the ending, but the action was good, the characters are memorable, and it was just fun to watch. Spider-Man 3 took a good series and ruined it.

@Proteus: God, those movies had fantastic frikkin' trailers, didn't they...?

I love Dead Man's Chest, it wins easily.

Dead Man's Chest was a very good sequel, Spider-Man 3 was just average.

Dead Man's Chest easily, mid over garbage anyday.

Spider-Man poops in Jack's bed. WAY better film.

Spidey 3 any day, don't even think this one requires an explanation