The Prestige vs. Collateral

6 comments

3 comments

Interesting. Both films fall into the very-good-but-not-great category. I think I'll go with the tale of obsession this time around.

I have to disagree with you; these are both in my Top 20. Prestige wins.

ear
ear

I will vote for the magical The Prestige in this line up.

I-Ching, Darwin, roll with it. Collateral's ending really let it down.

The Prestige wins for me here.

JRM
JRM

Both are in my top 100. The Prestige is just a tad greater.

The Prestige is one of my favorites. Collateral didn't wow me that much.

This is an incrediblly close matchup between two very good films. I thought I'd say otherwise originally, but my vote is actually going to go to The Prestige.

Collateral. Great, great performance by Cruise in this one...

The prestige wins here easily. And Hugh Jackman + Christan Bale > Jamie Fox + Tom Cruise