Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
17 comments
7 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/22/2009
I really should have expected this one to come along eventually. It's a very tough choice for me.
on 8/1/2009
aliens... easy
on 8/8/2009
Both are absolute classics of sci-fi action. But Aliens has the edge.
on 11/9/2009
Tough one but Aliens takes the gold.
on 3/10/2010
I give it to Aliens but making this choice actually hurt me.
on 4/24/2010
Aliens is clearly the superior film. Predator is good and tense, but ultimately is a very well made film with little in the way of subtext or character development. Aliens has both of those plus it's even tenser.
Aliens is the choice that packs the most wallop.
on 5/6/2010
Aliens vs Predator? This is a my worst nightmare. Aliens...Predator...okay Predator
James Cameron likes turning fairly stable female characters into angry, paranoid amazons. While I think Sarah Connor's transformation from the first Terminator movie into the roid rage commando in Terminator 2 was more horrifying, Ripley is definitely less likable in Aliens. She was tough in Alien, but she's more pissed off and gung ho in Aliens than she needs to be. I like ass-kicking women in movies, just not James Cameron's kind. Predator has more of a sense of humor and comparitively less obnoxious characters. There is no little kid or Paul Reiser to mess things up. The only thing Aliens beats Predator at is the final confrontation, because "What the hell are you?" isn't as awesome as "Get away from her, you bitch!". But I'd rather watch the rest of Predator over Aliens anytime.
on 7/14/2010
Aliens started out cheesy, but then picked things up considerably when the aliens themselves came into play. Predator, on the other hand,was cheesy from start to finish. Also, its music was repetitive, its acting weak, and its action rather dull. And, for a monster movie, it had a rather uninspiring monster. At least, in my opinion. Aliens, without a single shred of doubt.
I've always preferred the Alien's films over those dull repetitive Predator films.
on 2/9/2012
An easy one.Predator for sure.Aliens is massively overrated.
on 8/18/2012
Predator by far.
on 12/13/2012
Predator seems to have help up better than Aliens. I find it more entertaining and quotable.
Predator due to my misogyny.
The first Predator is fun and is still a hell of a lot better than its sequel, but I'll still put Aliens and even Alien over it.
Aliens.
on 4/9/2013
Ugh. Don't make me choose! Aliens by a HAIR.
Love 'em both....but Aliens just can't top Predator...
Predator is great, but Aliens is just better in every way. Also, I prefer the Xenomorph to the Predator.
on 6/20/2013
Aliens is a good action movie but I didn't appreciate it as much as most people do, I found Predator more entertaining and enjoyable.
its hard but i have to go with predator
on 7/7/2013
Aliens for me.
on 8/18/2013
aliens
on 7/16/2014
Both are great without question. Aliens-best in it's franchise but Predator wins this match up because it just visually holds up better than Aliens. "Come on do it... kill me I'm here, do it now kill me come on!" chills...
on 6/29/2015
I fucking LOVE Predator. But yeah I love Aliens more.
on 10/6/2015
Can't explain how much I love these two! Aliens is 6 and Predator is 7 on my list!
