Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
2 comments
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/6/2010
Ed Norton is such an amazing actor. One of the top three working today.
on 4/8/2010
Tough tough tough choice but I think I'm gonna go with 25th Hour soley because it is a much stronger performance from Norton and at their respective bests, I'll take Spike Lee over David Fincher any day.
on 4/15/2010
I love 25th Hour but Fight Club reigns supreme. Norton is fantastic in both films.
on 5/22/2011
Go Ed, Go!
on 6/4/2012
fight club wins but 25th hour is good too
on 9/18/2012
Norton's performance in 25th Hour was probably better but I prefer Fight Club. Its concept just sticks with you. Oh, and Ed is a beast!
on 4/30/2013
These are two of the best films I've ever seen, both in my top 20. Norton is amazing in both of them but there is no doubt he has amazing stories and subject material to work with in both. They are both similar films in that they tell us something about ourselves. I'll have to give my vote to Fight Club. The more serious 25th Hour contains one of the best plots that will stick with you and hammer your emotions afterwards. Fight Club had everything though, it's brilliant pace from scene to scene is unmatched in my opinion. BOTH ARE SO GREAT! Fight Club edges it though
on 4/8/2014
25th Hour. It is more cohesive and makes more sense. And it is more poignant, it really tells you something about those characters, makes you feel for them. That's the kind of connection I've never had with FC.
