Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
5 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 4/29/2013
Going with Skyfall since I've grown out of American Beauty. Just don't feel the same way about it anymore. Mendes, Deakins, Bardem -- everybody did a phenomenal job in Skyfall (except the writers).
Wasn't Kevin Spacey originally asked to play Javier Bardem's part? Wouldn't that have been awesome AND awkward?
Isn't Spacey too old for such a role now? His John Doe days are behind him.
Too old? Say whaaaat.
Whaaaat.
on 4/30/2013
Skyfall was great...but I need it to stand the test of time before it topples American Beauty...
on 12/22/2013
Haven't seen Beauty in a while, but it probably wins.
on 3/1/2015
I'll go with Sam Mendes's best film
American Beauty is far superior.
on 10/12/2015
American Beauty is fantastic but too slow for multiple views. Skyfall on the other hand....
on 3/26/2023
Agreed! American Beauty kills this matchup
on 4/16/2023
Skyfall is adrenaline pumping but American Beauty in my opinion is the magnum opus for Sam.