Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
3 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/29/2011
wow! ok, let me think... it's the greatest western of all times vs the greatest crime film of all time. godfather for now
on 3/2/2012
Another awesome matchup. The best crime film versus one of the best westerns. Godfather takes it.
on 3/11/2012
Once Upon a Time in the West wins for sure, Godfather sucks because its too booring and slow. Once Upon a Time in the West does still have its popularity while Godfather has gone pretty amode. Once Upon a Time in the West does also have a better story, and better acting and music, while Godfather dosen't have much of story and bad acting. I can definitely understand that Godfather has lost it's popularity years ago and that people dosen't like it anymore. So Once Upon a Time in the West is the winner.
I sense a great disturbance in LordVader's head.
on 3/12/2012
Godfather wins, but I did have to stop and think for a a minute. But a minute is all it took...
on 3/20/2012
A very close matchup. I have to go with The Godfather. I much finer film. Even more enjoyable is that of Godfather, not to mention the gold class acting.
on 5/9/2012
It's a fact. Indeed, the greatest mob-movie versus the greatest western. What isn't a fact is that Once Upon a Time is better. But if you ask me, it is ;)
on 5/20/2013
Well it seems Vader admires the Godfather just as much as I enjoy Star Wars. But has the Godfather really lost popularity as he claims repeatedly? As for OUATITW, i like it but i do think that maybe Leone stretched things too far this time. I prefer his GBU.
on 5/21/2013
Both top 40 films for me and both are masterpieces in every sense of the word. The Godfather has the edge.
on 12/29/2015
TGF is deserving of its status, but I simply prefer OUATITW. It has such a rich plot. And don’t get me started with the score and cinematography. Plus, it’s the only time I can recall seeing Fonda play the role of the antagonist. Fine performance might I add.
on 5/27/2018
Sorry! but, once upon a time in the west ¡Can't beat the best movie realize. i mind THE GODFATHER
Godfather
I prefer The Godfather epic.
on 5/28/2018
Both are very strong technically, though The Godfather has the stronger acting, and "West" the more legendary score. For now I'll take the barren beauty of "West."
