Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
2 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 12/13/2015
Avatar was pretty good, but the length gives Nightmare the nod.
I never saw the whole appeal of Avatar. Nightmare is a far stronger film.
Avatar by miles.
on 10/15/2016
Nightmare on Elm Street by Miles easy!
on 4/27/2017
Nightmare has issues in the third act, and the final plot resolution is weak. Avatar is kind of derivative and tedious, and goes overboard with its "look how pretty this is" shot selection, but it wins here.
on 6/11/2021
Avatar’s only good thing is the visuals effects, everything else falls flat. Nightmare rains supreme above it. It has superior characters, pacing, etc. Heck even the music is better. Avatar’s is just okay-ish, sounding generic and unmemorable; while Nightmare’s fits with the movie, feeling surreal, dream-like.. or, Nightmare-like I should say.