Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
8 comments
13 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/28/2010
Good fight!
on 2/28/2012
Great Fight. This one will go the distance with Saving Private Ryan finishing on top.
on 10/6/2012
The epicness in Gladiator is more than Private Ryan can handle.
on 7/13/2013
SPR for sure.
Are you not entertained!
on 7/14/2013
I agree with PiccoloKing. Gladiator was more satisfying than SPR, which I thought was rather overlong. The Extended Cut of Gladiator > SPR
Gladiator, but not by much. Gladiator is a top 20 film, but SPR is one of the honourable mentions which just misses out. Regardless, both are fantastic.
on 7/15/2013
SPR slaughters IMO.
on 9/2/2013
Going with Gladiator.
on 12/13/2013
Gladiator the more epic film.
on 6/10/2014
Ryab
Saving Ryan's Privates
on 9/27/2014
SPR but only because I'm a sucker for Tom Hanks' acting.
Gladiator
on 9/23/2015
Saving private ryan easily
on 5/1/2017
love the cast more in SPR and the beach scene is one of cinemas greatest, Gladiator is also epic, both are so great.
on 3/12/2018
I'm going with Saving Private Ryan for sure.
Saving Private Ryan hands down.
on 8/14/2018
Gladiator has the more compelling, better-written lead character, which gets further translated into the much stronger lead performance, for Crowe is a far better actor than Hanks. He could've easily pulled off Miller as well as Hanks did, but it's doubtful if Hanks could've owned a role like Maximus the way Crowe did. That's how I see it anyway.
Saving Private Ryan has more impact even though both are great films where we lose our lead by story's end.
on 8/15/2018
Crowe and Hanks carry these films, it's the supporting cast that let them down. Gladiator>Saving Private Ryan
on 8/15/2020
Saving Private Ryan recommended superior.