Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/3/2010
Wow...this is a tough call, but I've got to go with The Godfather.
on 10/11/2010
People shouldn't have to make these kinds of decisions, but The Godfather wins.
on 3/2/2012
Godfather wins.
on 9/4/2016
Godfather 6-0
on 12/30/2017
Close but Chinatown
Chinatown was more coherent and compelling to me!
on 1/1/2018
Very good contest. Um.... can't pick hahahaha....
I love The Godfather, but I'm not really into this gangster shit. Chinatown is way more my cup of tea.
on 3/5/2021
Both of them fit the definition of almost flawless films and they have 2 of the most compelling stories in any film ever. The Godfather has a bigger scope but I'm choosing Chinatown for the now
on 3/30/2021
Chinatown ALL THE WAY. Jack Nicholson is also a far better actor than those in that booring Godfather.
