Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
14 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/7/2009
Now that's ironic.
on 7/23/2009
haha How funny! very ironic. wonder if i will get 'Not Another Teen Movie' and 'American Pie'. I've always thought the spoof version is better
on 3/30/2010
lol xD
on 8/19/2010
Ironic, yes; close, no. Scream is much better than its parody.
on 6/22/2012
Both flicks generated a unecessary pile of bad sequels,,which in a way,defined genres that produced tons and tons of bad movies. Despite all this bad legacy,they're very good movies by their own merits. Scream all the way.
Scream. It put a twist on the horror genre.
on 9/21/2012
Scary movie 100%, nothing made me laugh like that film did.
Scary Movie...I can't help it. Love it. Definitely love Scream....but I just can't help myself on this one...
It's like the Scary Movie writers didn't get that Scream was slasher satire in the first place.
on 11/16/2012
Scream undoubtedly wins out of the two
on 3/21/2013
Horror satire or horror spoof? Scary Movie is hilarious.
on 9/7/2013
Scream wins without a doubt. Scream is one of the greatest films of all time with perfect pacing, acting, dialogue, etc. Scary Movie is a cheep excuse for a film and just feels like a long YouTube video....disgraceful.
Scream wins!
on 8/7/2015
Yes, Scary Movie is undoubtedly hilarious, but Scream is the movie I'd much rather watch.
on 1/22/2018
Scream.....it was actually a trailblazer for a genre that needed a reboot.
on 5/12/2018
Scream is memorable and recent good better than Scary Movie...
Scream is far better.......
on 5/18/2019
As much as I hated Scream, the parody of it was so much worse. In fact, I consider Scary Movie to be the worst franchise in existence.
on 4/20/2020
UncleFok is right. Scary Movie is a dumb film, but then it perhaps was made by dumb people that couldn't realize that Scream already is a satire. And then, a pointless movie that doesn't even justify its existence.
on 5/22/2023
Scream is not nearly so clever as it pretends to be, although it lacks the cloying self-referential nature of its innumerable sequels. Scary Movie is deliberately stupid, but it's stupid even beyond its deliberation. A few chuckles aren't worth 88 minutes of tedium. I very reluctantly pick Scream
