Secret Window vs. Disturbia



Two great thrillers. I have a soft spot for Disturbia. Shut up.

I'm not sure what it is, but I too could watch Disturbia over and over.

Disturbia was a great surprise. Smart(ish), fun, good acting, and lots of genuine suspense. Secret Window was a great disappointment. Joyless, thrill-less, predictable as hell, with an easy to figure out "twist".

I enjoy Disturbia, but thought it was totally predictable. Perhaps Secret Window is as well, but I didn't think it was to quite the same extent. And then Johnny Depp tips this one in SW's favor.

Yeah, both pale imitations.

Damm I wish I had a neighborhood like the one in Disturbia! For me it's Disturbia all the way.