Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/5/2009
The Man of Iron trumps the Man of Steel. At least for me....
on 12/6/2009
Steel over iron and any other super-heroic alloy
on 12/7/2009
Thats a tough one!
on 12/9/2009
WOW...um.. I would love to be in the middle on this one.. but if I had to pick who I would want to date.. um.. SUPERMAN!!!
on 1/17/2010
Superman is great, but Iron Man with Downey is better
on 2/23/2010
Superman has something Iron Man lacks; a really compelling villain.
on 5/13/2010
Best origin film all-time? Iron Man easily beats Superman. I love Christopher Reeve but Superman really doesn't hold up well over time.
on 5/11/2012
Superman had the stronger cast.
Superman is the grandfather of all superhero movies. My reason for choosing it though is that it has a certain magical quality that surrounds the entire movie. Some of it has to do with John Williams's majestic score, but the cast and the superb script play big parts too. Iron Man is an excellent superhero movie as well and it gives Superman a decent run for its money, but the Man of Steel wins out in the end.
Iron Man wins. It can't hang with Superman II, but it easily outlasts the original.
on 8/13/2013
Superman wins
on 12/24/2013
This one's tough. But I guess I'll go with Superman for its stronger influence (no pun intended).
DC wins over Marvel.
on 1/1/2014
Iron Man
on 12/25/2015
DC>Marvel so Superman>Iron Man my logic
on 12/14/2017
The one that actually made it onto the National Film Registry.
on 10/18/2020
iron man >= superman 2 > superman
Iron Man is much better.
on 3/19/2021
Iron Man to me is like Superman 78 to people in their 50s, it’s the film that made me thought a man could fly
on 4/7/2021
superman 78 is much better, iron man 1 is overrated
on 7/18/2021
One of the few times I choose an mcu movie over dc. superman is great but it didn't age well
on 11/21/2022
As much as I like and respect Iron Man, I have to give the win to Reeve
on Feb 16
Superman wins because Superman I really like the actor Christopher Reeve But that doesn't mean I don't like the actor who plays Iron Man it's just you he doesn't drive me crazy the way it's written
