Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
7 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 12/13/2010
Disaster porn or freezing disaster! TDAT wins it
Cinema would miss either of them, but i'll go for the Day After Tomorrow, only because it came first. 2012 was just a copy of a copy of a copy of Roland Emmerichs other films and I don't think i'm alone in saying it was truly awful.
(Thats supposed to Cinema wouldn't miss either of them - Wouldn't)
on 5/10/2011
Wow, is there a way to skip this one all together? Both of these films were horrible, but I'll go with Day After Tom. since it's older
The Day After Tomorrow, but definitely not because it came first. TDAT may not be good, but 2012 is unwatchable crap.
on 1/17/2012
No, neither of them are great films. But you don't watch a disaster film expecting greatness. You watch a disaster film to watch buildings fall, and cities to flood, and things explode and people escape (or fall victim to) death. So, without judging the acting, or the overall plot line, and just judging by visual effects and the disaster itself, TDAT is the definite winner.
on 10/3/2012
I enjoyed 2012, only for the special effects, they were amazing in my opinion. But yeah, TDAT wins
on 8/31/2013
Both are bad films, but at least The Day After Tomorrow wasn't terribly boring. I didn't like it, but I will admit it has some good things to it, which keeps it from being a truly terrible film. 2012, on the other hand, is so boring and so vapid that it's almost unwatchable. The Day After Tomorrow wins.
on 9/10/2013
Damn, what an equal fight! Well, almost. Both movies remind me of one another probably cuz both are (earth's) disaster films. The Day After tomorrow has the edge. Better story.
on 10/3/2013
TDAT pretty easily
on 12/2/2013
It cepe of that all the freeze what it shaves on to every going to freeze clot of ending of world
on 2/17/2018
2012 Is soooo long. The Day After Tomorroiw makes more sense.
on 3/11/2018
2012
Both films are too cheesy and ridiculous at their core but 2012 was more entertaining.
