Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
7 comments
19 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 5/5/2011
Very close. I prefer How to Train Your Dragon over either of them, but I'd say these two are on the same level.
on 5/6/2011
Tangled was surprisingly great but Toy Story 3 surpassed my ridiculously high expectations so it wins out in this case.
TS3 blows Tangled away.
on 5/18/2011
Tangled was cute, but the last five minutes alone make me give this to TS3.
Loved them both, but I'm gonna say Toy Story 3 without hesitation. And I agree with nclysander, the ending of Tangled wasn't that great.
on 5/27/2011
Tangled is fun, but for some reason, I can't seem to get past the fact that a traditional Disney princess movie was animated by computers. Toy Story 3 is technically amazing, but I can't seem to get past the fact that it is so damned hard to watch. I mean, seriously, I don't think any movie has manipulated my emotions and devastated me on quite the same level, even on second viewing. Tangled, I've only just seen, so it's really fresh in my mind. I'm letting my chart sort itself out on this one for now.
on 5/31/2011
I admit right now that Tangled is one of my all time favorite movies. And I love it a lot more than Toy Story 3. Malie, nclysander, I gotta disagree with you guys the ending was wonderful. But not as emotional as the Lantern scene. It's great. johnmason; you do have a point that it isn't in hand drawn animation but the CG animation was beautiful. I loved Tangled. No arguement.
on 8/18/2011
both of these were just a failure
on 8/29/2011
wrong, none of these failed but were in fact at least good while toy story 3 was a great trilogy ender
Disney/Pixar should be the ONLY company making these animated films. Seriously!
on 9/3/2011
Malie, Siskebert: I must not have stated my thoughts clearly. "Tangled was cute, but the last five minutes [of TS3] alone make me give this to TS3." I wasn't trying to rag on Tangled's ending, which was fine, but rather to say that Toy Story 3's was so moving as to make any other decision besides the one I made out of consideration (for me).
And, Ellemac, while I agree that PIXAR is the most consistent of contemporary animation studios, would you really want to put Dreamworks out of commission after their brilliant work on How To Train Your Dragon? I'm all for pro-PIXARism, but let's not go overboard here.
on 5/12/2013
Toy Story 3 definitely better; an emotional ending to a series that I had grown up with. Tangled is also great and showed positive signs for the future of Disney
Toy Story 3 is my favorite animated film.
Toy Story 3 by destruction....
on 2/11/2014
Toy Story 3. I enjoyed Tangled but TS3 was something else.
on 5/7/2015
I actually prefer Tangled. I thought it was more impressive.
on 8/3/2015
Toy Story 3 wins by a mile.
Yeah, Tangled can't touch Toy Story 3.
on 12/23/2015
Several years later, I'm firmly in the Tangled camp on this one.
I love tangled but it is not as good as toy story 3
on 2/14/2016
Tangled gets my vote. This movie surprised me. Just like The Princess and the Frog. But that's another story.
on 3/5/2016
Tangled was just another by-the-books generic average disney film.
on 11/25/2016
Toy Story 3 is by far superior.
on 1/14/2017
Both Disney movies are great. Well, I thought at first that Toy Story 3 is the best, and Tangled is the worst.
on 2/20/2017
Toy Story 3 is a far better movie.
on 11/14/2018
Toy Story 3 obviously, way better than Tangled was...
on 11/25/2019
Toy Story 3 by far.
