Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
15 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/10/2009
Tough choice. I love both these movies but I am into the macabre way too much not to pick Se7en
Agreed. Both are great but Se7en is ever so slightly better for me.
on 10/6/2009
I don't get the big deal about 7. It was very ordinary and predictable to me. American History X takes this one.
on 10/24/2009
Ahhh. I'd have to say Se7en because of 1) David Fincher, and 2) the relationship between Brad Pitt's character and Morgan Freeman's character.
on 3/26/2010
se7en edges out , only because it makes it feel it's easy to make a thriller.
on 2/5/2012
Se7en is full of thrills and has one of the greatest finales in history.
on 4/14/2012
I've seen Se7en multiple times and just saw American History X again recently. This isn't close for me. I liked American History X, but it didn't have nearly the impact on me that Se7en did.
on 4/21/2012
I loved everything about Se7en. The acting, the story, the director. But I do think it's a little overrated. American History X blew my mind.
on 4/22/2012
Both films have very depressing endings (which are totally warranted and help to enhance the quality of both films). I'll go American History X because it's the only Ed Norton performance I like and had more impact with the ending.
on 7/12/2012
Se7en didn't have Edward Furlong. Plus, it's the best thriller ever.
on 11/18/2012
Eddie Furlong one of the most overrated actors in film history.
on 6/6/2014
I preferred AHX, plus I think se7en is quite overrated.
I agree with bananaboy.
on 2/27/2015
Se7en is a lot better, the acting in american history x is not good, other than nortan and his brothers performance. Also the story was kind of boring in some places of history x.
on 6/22/2015
Seven for me as well.
on 2/11/2016
These movies are equally fabulous in their own right. Both endings are magnificent, but American History X manages to get closer to the feels.
on 7/2/2016
AHX is great, but Se7en is my favorite Fincher movie.
Gotta go AHX in a close one...
