The Orphanage vs. Birds of America

0 comments

0 comments

on 6/29/2009

Now this is an appropriate face-off: two cinéma vérité flicks, both horror, both great in their own right. But if you ask me to choose between the two, Cloverfield gets the edge. Why? Because there isn't a giant frickin' monster eating cameramen in Diary--that's why!

on 6/29/2009

Well, crap... Damn site cycled through so fast it left the comment on the wrong match-up. This should be Cloverfield vs. Diary of the Dead, not some bird flick and The Orphanage.

on 8/2/2009

Hilarious. You had me pretty confused there. I've yet to see Birds of America w/ Matthew Perry. I thought you were cleverly calling it a horror flick due to how bad it is :D The Orphanage rocks though.

on 8/16/2009

Well, now I'm posed with a conundrum... I was going to repost Magus's original comment in the right matchup, but now we've got a whole conversation here. What....to....DO. (Spoiler alert: I copied the original post over into Diary of the Dead vs. Cloverfield.)