Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
22 comments
10 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 4/10/2010
GoodFellas is more popular, but I prefer Se7en.
on 4/14/2011
Se7en is very good movie indeed, But GoodFellas is definitely better.
on 6/29/2011
Seven is thrillingly horrific and the clear winner here.
on 9/15/2011
"Goodfellas" has really never done much for me. I see the appeal and even kinda appreciate it, but it's not one I'll come back to.
on 1/23/2012
Se7en scores an easy win here.It's just too damn good.
on 2/17/2012
Goodfellas.
on 4/7/2012
Im going with Se7en here.
on 4/15/2012
Se7en is great but, Goodfellas 100%
on 11/26/2012
Tommy De Vito may lose his temper if he sees John Doe.
on 11/27/2012
Two of my favorite directors (Scorsese and Fincher) and two of my favorite actors (De Niro and Pitt) and two amazing movies, but I am leaning slightly towards GoodFellas.
on 5/29/2013
Goodfellas by far.
2 of the best films of the 90's but Goodfellas is THE best film of the 90's in my opinion.
on 6/17/2013
GoodFellas is this package of brilliance from Scorsese and Pileggi. Fincher is my favorite director, and Se7en is a masterpiece, but GoodFellas comes in as the overall better film.
on 8/21/2013
WOW. Both changed my life, but I gotta go with Goodfellas, it's my favorite mob movie. Se7en is better than Fight Club in my opinion.
After my last viewing a month or two ago Se7en jumped quite a bit on my list. One of the films it passed...Goodfellas.
on 10/11/2013
Even Se7en cannot surpass the brilliance of Goodfellas.
on 12/11/2013
To be honest, Se7en didn't insight me, I liked some parts but didn't love the overall film.
on 7/4/2014
Im nit the Biggest Gangster fan but Goodfellas is one of the better films but overall i just love Seven way more but both are masterful!
I really enjoy Goodfellas but Se7en is a much more thrilling viewing experience.
Slight edge to Se7en...
on 9/5/2014
goodfellas by a good margin, se7en is still a top 20 film tho
fellas
Goodfellas definetely is one of the best scorsese movies ever!! se7en is so damn overrated!!
on 10/16/2014
Tough one but I think Goodfellas wins this one
on 1/23/2015
Goodfellas is better in every respect
on 7/29/2015
7
on 9/1/2015
Se7en for sure.
on 7/4/2020
Fincher over Scorsese here.
on 6/4/2022
So close but Seven is scary good.
No contest: Goodfellas all the way. Se7en is good, but I still struggle to see why so many people consider it a masterpiece; it's just a fairly standard (albeit very well-executed) detective flick to me...
on 7/27/2022
Goodfellas without a doubt
on 8/9/2022
Okay, over some retrospect, I think my opinion here is changing. I think Se7en brought out more emotion for me. Goodfellas built up an entire life and tore it down with pure style. But Se7en is a gripping crime thriller masterpiece. A complex and philosophically rich movie with some of the best cinematography I've ever seen. Even Goodfellas can't compare to it
Overall, I think I'll give a very narrow edge to Se7en
Without a doubt GoodFellas deserves the win here.
on 9/1/2022
Seven became an instant fav and it holds up on rewatch, but Goodfellas is the best of the 90's.
on 9/4/2022
Changed my mind, Goodfellas wins here
on 4/16/2023
Tough but has to be Goodfellas
on 7/23/2023
GoodFellas is so thoroughly entertaining it makes 2,5 hours fly by like it's a second. Se7en is amazing in its own right and has that deliciously dark ending but i think the winner is still Scorcese here.
on 12/22/2023
The mob masterpiece triumphs here.