Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
31 comments
16 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/13/2009
This decision is the most difficult since I'm in flickchart!
on 8/4/2009
Brutal choice, can't make a rational decision so my gut wins out with the dogs.
on 8/24/2009
Dogs v's Fellas, raw v's accomplished. This time it's Scorcese next time, no doubt, it'll be Quentin.
on 8/28/2009
These two films could not possibly be more different, and the gap in quality couldn't be much wider.
on 10/13/2009
GoodFellas. The characters in GoodFellas were a lot more real than those in Reservoir Dogs. A bunch of talking walking gangster cliches.
on 11/10/2009
Love Scorsese, but it's Reservoir Dogs for me.
on 12/6/2009
Gotta be Goodfellas, although both movies are a lot of fun.
on 12/7/2009
Goodfellas is one of the few gangster movies I like because it isn't one that glorifies the lifestyle (like Scarface). BUT, Reservoir Dogs is mythic. RD ftw.
on 12/25/2009
Tarantino vs. Scorsese? gotta say Reservoir Dogs
on 12/30/2009
Goodfellas but reservoir dogs is great
on 2/4/2010
For sheer entertainment value, Reservoir Dogs.
on 6/28/2010
I love both of these movies are great and it's almost a coin toss for me. I'm going to have to pick Goodfellas here but both are in my Top 20
on 11/12/2010
tough
on 3/14/2011
Wow boy, now that's a tough one! How to choose one masterpiece from the other?
on 10/25/2011
Gun to head. Two great films by great directors. You are invested in the the characters a little more.
on 1/20/2012
I'll flip a coin.Dogs it is.
on 2/16/2012
Goodfellas by far.
on 4/10/2012
Goodfellas on this one. Only just though.
on 6/5/2012
Dogs is more entertaining.Goodfellas loses its way in the second half.RD is great throughout.The dialogue is delightful in both the films though.
Goodfellas smack around the Dogs. Pure ass kicking right here...
on 7/7/2012
Dogs is a bit more special to me. I saw RD before GoodFellas and instantly fell in love with it. I still believe RD is Tarantino's best. I love GoodFellas but not as much as I love RD. Also, I liked Casino more than GF.
on 11/3/2012
Goodfellas for sure. Reservoir Dogs is a great debut for Tarantino, but against Scorsese's masterpiece it doesn't win.
Reservoir Dogs by a longshot
on 1/3/2013
GoodFellas is good, fellas.
on 1/4/2013
Dogs for me, but not by much.
Although I very much enjoyed Goodfellas, I think it's a little overrated. Resevoir is my favourite of the two although it's very close. Both are good films.
on 1/30/2013
FUUUUUUCK
Do you guys think its backwards that Samuel L. Jackson was in Goodfellas and not Reservoir Dogs?
Reservoir Dogs. I really liked Goodfellas, but that constant narration got a little annoying after a while.
on 3/11/2013
Goodfellas is sure amazing but for me...for now...Reservoir Dogs easily wins! I will however watch Goodfellas in the upcoming week and my opinion may change
Are you gonna bark all day little doggie, or are you gonna bite? Who would win in a fight: Mr. Blonde or Tommy?
on 4/6/2013
Reservoir Dogs is better for me....Yet both are in my top 10
@JC13- Mr Blonde would win as would Reservoir Dogs in this matchup...The dialogue in RD is rarely matched, the characters, the plot, the execution and the fact that this is Tarantino's directorial debut and how amazing it turned out to be....Dogs wins!
on 7/21/2013
Reservoir Dogs wins by a bit.
on 7/28/2013
RD by a nose.
on 8/21/2013
Oh gosh. I gotta go Goodfellas, although Reservoir Dogs is Tarantino's second best film. Both in my Top 20.
on 9/3/2013
mmmmmmmm I choose Reservoir Dogs for being SLIGHTLY more entertaining. I'm not bashing on Goodfelas though. Very close call, both in my top 20.
on 9/4/2013
Goodfellas by a wide margin.
on 2/14/2014
As much as I like QT's debut, Scorsese's masterpiece is the winner. It's a technical marvel which showcases the director's very best. GoodFellas is a film which has everything.
Fellas beats Dogs.
on 4/10/2014
Scorsese Vs.Tarantino ya I am going Tarantino
on 10/6/2014
Two great gangsta movies
on 8/2/2015
Reservoir Doggystyle by a hair.
on 7/4/2016
Reservoir Dogs............ best gangsta film in my opinion
on 9/17/2017
Goodfellas for sure.
on 2/28/2018
Goodfellas is better but i prefer Reservoir Dogs
on 3/5/2018
Dogs
on 3/6/2018
Both are good, but I don't love either. Given the choice, I'd rather go back and watch Goodfellas. Overall, I probably prefer Tarantino's body of work over Scorcese's, but I really didn't rate Reservoir Dogs when I saw it.
on 1/31/2021
Reservoir dogs must be in my top 30 but goodfellas is a top 10 material
