Rebecca vs. Strangers on a Train



This one is pretty tough. I watched SOAT yesterday and Rebecca just barely and both were great. I think I slightly preferred Strangers on a Train.

On second thought, I think I'll take Rebecca.

I'll take Rebecca for sure though both are amazing

Pretty tough matchup. I personally thought Rebecca took too long to get going. Much of the first 30+ minutes was fairly needless in the grand scheme of things. I realize a good movie needs a foundation to work from, but much of the dialogue that took place before the marriage of the second Mrs. De Winter was pointlessly detailed, like all the conversation between her and her employer. It was just too much. Very good move though after they get married and go back to Mandalay. Strangers though is very efficient with its scenes. Thus, I'm giving it the edge.

Good matchup. Rebecca for me!