Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
2 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/15/2009
If they get rid of Jar-Jar, Jake Lloyd and give the script a few re-writes, I'd still go with Fellowship.
on 12/7/2009
im a star wars and a lotr super geek. however this would be tougher if episode 1 wasnt my least favorite in the series.
on 4/14/2010
Episode I is my least favorite Star Wars movie for sure, but I don't get the hate for it. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Jar Jar Binks be damned. Anyway, Fellowship wins this.
on 7/15/2010
First in a trilogy vs. first in a trilogy. "Fellowship" exceeded expectations though, and was one of the best movie experiences of my life. "Phantom Menace" underwhelmed--and that's putting it politely.
on 12/10/2012
Fellowship. No contest.
on 2/20/2015
The Fellowship of the Ring hugs The Phantom Menace
Even for the biggest Star Wars fan like myself, LOTR is the easy pick here...
Even as a fan of chocolate, I can't pick chocolate covered shit over vanilla ice cream.
on 2/22/2015
Episode I definitely gets more hate than it deserves but it doesn't come close to the excellent Fellowship.
on 2/23/2015
Hmm, good for Episode I
on 2/25/2015
Fellowship
on 3/29/2015
No question which wins here. Fellowship of the Ring.
on 8/7/2015
Why? Why would Nosferatu do this?
on 9/30/2015
Even Peter Jackson doesn't give up.
on 1/9/2017
The best joke of this site! The worst film of the year vs the best film of the year?
on 1/22/2020
Lord of the Rings owns here..
Neither movies did anything for me. Lord Of The Rings is terribly overrated and Phantom Menace is the only Star Wars i struggle to watch (not the only bad one but the one with very few redemptive qualities for me to rewatch it). I can't tell you off the top of my head so I'll let my chart decide. I may be surprise...
on 6/15/2020
Although i'm not a big of Toliken, then FOTR is more worthy than that awful Phantom Menace.