Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
12 comments
14 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/21/2010
Jaws is awesome filmmaking. It even beats LOTR
on 12/31/2011
Yea, I'm picking Jaws as well.
on 5/12/2013
Its definitely Fellowship. Its my favorite film of all time, yes but there's more to it. Whenever I watch FOTR, there is a certain excitement I get. Every ten minutes, there is a scene in the film I just love. It helps when a 3 hour movie has scenes every ten minutes that you love! It makes the entire film that much more AMAZING! Jaws, not really! I loved the first half. It had great build up and a certain mystery to it but the last half bored me to death. It made for a mediocre film. This thought on Jaws may change in the future but it'll never beat FOTR...That there is a promise!!
on 5/15/2013
I love LOTR; all of them are in my top 10 and FOTR is the best of the three IMO. But none can compete with Jaws, and that's saying A LOT considering how much I love LOTR.
on 5/24/2013
Jaws all day every day for me.
I don't think Jaws is as exceptional as everyone else thinks it is, but it's still good. It's pretty suspenseful, it has memorable characters and lines, it's good stuff. It's not as entertaining or as well directed as Raiders, but is definitely better than Jurassic Park. Fellowship of the Ring remains one of the best fantasy movies ever made, and it is in my opinion the best of the trilogy. There are not nearly as many comic relief moments as in The Two Towers (and it also isn't nearly as boring) and it isn't as messy as Return of the King (which I do still really love as well).
on 8/21/2013
Fellowship by a freakin' hair...
on 10/29/2013
Jaws is the true classic winner here.
Oh goodness! Jaws is the original blockbuster. It's in my top 20 and could legitimately make its way to my top 10 if I give it another watch some time in the future. But FOTR is epitome of epic. Cinematography wise, such a beautiful film. Story wise, such a rich and engulfing movie. Acting wise, such powerful performances. FOTR is nearly perfect in every regard.
on 11/22/2013
I'm going to have to go with Jaws on this one.
on 11/23/2013
I loved Jaws! I didn't expect to, but I did. I found it to be intense and it had great acting all around (especially Robert Shaw), and it was also pretty terrifying. That being said Fellowship means so much more to me so it wins.
on 11/24/2013
TLOTR gets the win here folks. Jaws is a classic, but the two towers is just the better film.
on 12/18/2013
Fellowship
on 5/6/2014
Nothimg torches LOTR
on 6/8/2014
Jaws is wayyyyyyyyyyy better
on 6/15/2014
I'll go with Jar's.
I'll go with Jars.
I really enjoy Jaws but Fellowship of the Ring wins here
on 1/10/2015
Two top 20 films for me. Fellowship wins.
on 9/9/2015
Jaws is simpler and yes, better.
Love jaws but it is fellowship man
Jaws is far better than Raiders and far worse than Raiders. I'd mean, MysticSpoon is probably a ignorant with no arguments.
on 9/10/2015
Jaws is a very tense movie about a shark but The Lord of the Rings is the most EPIC fantasy film franchise ever made.
on 6/28/2018
Both are good but Fellowship is my effort here..
on 8/18/2018
Jaws is still good but it can't beat LotR here..
on 12/12/2019
Love LOTR but it’s jaws here.
on 6/11/2021
99.99% of movies can’t compare to LOTR, but Jaws is one of the few exceptions. Truly a special movie.
on 8/1/2021
Family friendly fantasy epic or realistic thriller summer blockbuster? Sauron > Bruce.
any LOTR beats jaws for me
on 7/8/2023
ah yes, pitting the original blockbuster film against a book adaptation that was the worst in it's trilogy.
on 10/23/2023
JAWS was way more intense and real. ROTK is epic but goofy after a while . JAWS is a more serious and powerful movie.