Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/28/2008
In a lot of ways you can actually look at Three Kings as a remake of Three Amigos. Obviously Wahlberg is Martin. Both Martin and Wahlberg are the only members who are shot and it's their "Lucky Day" that they have both survived by the end of their respective films. Clooney is Chase. He's "Dusty" throughout the entire movie and is the only one who would probably have reservoir lip balm in the middle of the desert. I think Ice Cube and Martin Short are both the shortest of their threesomes and are comparatively trigger happy. But, there isn't a single singing horse in all of Three Kings, so the vote goes to Amigos. Nice try, Three Kings, nice try.
I gotta say, as fun as Three Amigos is, I was really blown away with the look of Three Kings - great use of color and cinematography. Visually one of my favorites.
on 7/2/2009
JKupfer311 I love the match up and the reasoning for the vote, I just liked Kings better.
on 7/19/2009
So close...Amigos by a nose.
on 7/31/2009
Gotta go with Three Kings here.
on 11/14/2009
I think I'm going with Three Kings but I wish it featured more sewing..
on 10/4/2012
Three Kings, but I love Three Amigos
There is absolutely no question that Three Kings is the better movie and I love it. But I grew up with Amigos...and I'll laugh at the Invisible Swordsman till my dying day...
on 6/2/2013
Three Amigos is a classic...but Three Kings takes it.
on 11/9/2017
I'll take the Three Amigos. I understand that comedy is subjective, but this film is a classic that still delivers 30 years later. Three Kings does not have that kind of staying power, no way.
