Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
16 comments
20 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/21/2012
Goodfellas by a mile.
Goodfellas. It is a crime classic.
on 10/11/2012
GBU for now. Tough call.
Wow. Rough one. Goodfellas for now, but I reserve the right to change my mind. Two great ones...
on 2/10/2013
I love Tuco in GBU, I think he and Joe Pesci are alike.
on 2/19/2013
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly...fellas.
on 6/29/2013
GBU by a mile.
Sergio Leone wins
on 8/30/2013
Goodfellas wins. I enjoyed The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, but Goodfellas made a huge impact at a young age.
Not even the GoodFellas could win against Blondie in a Mexican stand-off.
on 9/6/2013
Goodfellas just has to win here.
on 9/12/2013
Goodfellas has the slight edge.
on 1/17/2014
Fine matchup. GBU for me.
on 4/23/2014
Cool matchup. GBU for me.
on 5/25/2014
Tg :-) - TB >:-( - tU :-{}
on 10/29/2014
GoodFellas wins for now, though GBU needs a rewatch first before I can confidently say that GoodFellas is the better movie
on 1/15/2015
The GoodFellas, the BadFellas and the UglyFellas
Goodfellas is one of my favorites, but GBU is in my top 3 of all time
on 7/24/2015
GBU.
The Good the Bad and the Ugly over any Scorsese film.
on 6/23/2018
Goodfellas is much sensational outstanding.
on 3/8/2020
Good
Fellas
Goodfellas
Goodfellas is so much better
Goodfellas with ease
Goodfellas by a longshot
GBU isn't even the best Western Goodfellas easily
Goodfellas by a mile
Joe Pesci's performance > Clint Eastwood Goodfellas
Writting Goodfellas > GBU Goodfellas
Directing Goodfellas > GBU
Goodfellas forever
Goodfellas is better
on 12/10/2020
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly can't beat the slick style of GoodFellas.
on 2/20/2021
Two incredible top 10 all time films. Give the nod to Eastwood as this was the best Western ever and Goodfellas is the second best gangster film behind Godfather.
on 5/19/2021
Goodfellas has a better cast of characters and far more enjoyable on a consistent basis.
