Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
15 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/18/2010
Tarantino wishes he could make a film with as much intensity as Taxi Driver.
on 4/22/2011
Excruciating decision. In the end, I chose Taxi Driver, if only because Reservoir Dogs is not seen as something of a remake.
on 8/10/2012
As brilliant a film and as compelling and relatable a story as Taxi Driver is, it simply isn't as fun as Reservoir Dogs, if i had a choice of watching either fiilm right now (these two films being my only choices) i'd choose Reservoir Dogs. that's how i feel at this current point in time about it anyway...
on 1/7/2013
Travis Bickle.
Reservoir Dogs reminds me of my good ol' days -- you know -- swearing, gunfire, stealing etc.. Good times. But Taxi Driver is the better film, no doubt.
Reservoir Dogs is a highly reminiscent work.
Reminiscent of Ringo Lam. Ohh!! Oh!!!
Both in my top 50, but I slightly prefer the Dogs.
on 1/30/2013
Gotta go with Dogs.
on 8/30/2013
WOW! The hardest matchup I have ever come across! First off, it's pretty much the best from the two directors, Scorcese and Tarantino. Second, they are both classic masterpieces that have been so thoroughly absorbed into our culture. I would have to say Taxi Driver.. but just barely. I'm letting the rankings decide. You have to understand that I love both of these with all my heart and they have made a huge impact. Done.
Taxi Driver. Homerun.
on 9/27/2013
Reservoir Dogs wins a close one.
on 9/28/2013
Taxi Driver. A bigger impact and more of a classic
on 4/24/2014
Taxi Driver is the more original one here
Them Dogs
on 11/3/2014
Scorsese, you Got it
on 10/12/2015
Taxi Driver is the better film
on 10/13/2015
Reservoir dogs without question. taxi driver is a good film , but to me Scorsese made much better films Casino , Goodfellas . gangs, departed are all better imo
on 7/4/2016
Reservoir Dogs. Taxi Driver is pretty boring
Gotta go with the Dogs
on 8/16/2020
Gotta go Taxi Driver but mannn
on 12/26/2020
Reservoir dogs is great but Taxi Driver...
on 9/28/2022
Scorsese's best vs. Tarantino's roughest. I love both but its really no contest, Scorsese wins!
on 1/29/2023
As much as I love Reservoir Dogs, it ain't beating Taxi driver
