Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/2/2009
Well this is daunting, going to go with The Green Mile purely because of the impact it had on me.
on 5/12/2010
Both of these films had a HUGE impact on me. Both have casts to die for. I adore The Green Mile, and it's in my Top 20, but if I have to point to any one thing that nudges TDK over TGM, I guess it has to be Heath Ledger's Joker. These films are both indelibly burned into my memory, and I love them.
on 6/19/2010
The Green Mile is incredible. I have it in my top 10, but I have Dark Knight in my top 5.
on 7/2/2010
Personally, I think both are highly over-rated. "Green Mile" was interesting, but it was predictable enough that its payoff didn't resonate with me. I like that "Dark Knight" has a lot of allegorical layers, but it's flawed as well. Still, I'm taking Batman here.
on 8/12/2010
I loved Green Mile, but in the end i still have to vote for Dark Knight.
on 1/5/2012
The Green Mile is by far supirior. The Dark Knight is not even close to compare with The Green Mile. The Green Mile wins for sure.
on 3/2/2012
Both mind blowing epics. But Dark Knight takes it out.
on 1/13/2013
yeah, these aren't really in the same category but also a difficult choice. tempted to vote for the green mile just because im sick of superhero movies now, but then, the dark knight is much more than a superhero film
I don't mind going the opposite way here. The Green Mile it is....
The Dark Knight wins pretty easily even if it was Shawshank i would still pick Dark Knight.
on 4/1/2015
Boy, oh boy, I'm far more in debate than I was when I commented on this one five years ago...
Green Mile
The Green Mile is excellent but it doesn't match The Dark Knight.
on 9/2/2019
The dark knight
on 12/15/2020
The Green Mile has much more coherent storytelling.
on 3/27/2021
The Green Mile ALL THE WAY.
on 10/22/2022
The Green Mile, for sure.