Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
17 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/30/2009
'The Dark Knight' is fantastic, no doubt. I just think X2 is more enjoyable and fun.
on 11/9/2009
I like every X-Men movie more than The Dark Knight.
on 12/29/2009
The Dark Knight, but X2 is a blast for sure.
on 3/9/2010
X-2 is the least awful of the X-Men movies but really, so what? Besides this is Dark Knight we're talking about here.
on 5/13/2010
In the best sequels of all-time division, these two are fighting it out for the bronze medal at this point. Iron Man 2 and Spider-Man 2 top them both but the bronze goes to.......... X2: X-Men United. Congrats to the mutants!
on 7/28/2010
X2 YEAH!!!
The Dark Knight over all X-Men movies.
on 7/29/2010
There was a time when X2 was my all-time favorite comic book movie. Then it was eclipsed by Spider-Man 2. Then it was demolished by The Dark Knight. It's still a fantastic movie, but gimme Batman.
on 2/24/2011
X-men 2 showed us that superhero films could be great, the Dark Knight proved it. X2 may be a fun, stylish, well acted popcorn flick with great action set pieces, but The Dark Knight was a harrowing and sprawling crime epic that changes our perception of what a super hero film could be forever. It has yet to be matched.
on 3/28/2011
Honestly, X2 is the better all around film. Both are great adaptations but X2 simply delivers more range, more depth and the better action. Can't wait to see Singer/Vaughn bring the X-Men back to this quality with X-Men First Class.
on 6/17/2011
X2 by quite a way.
on 8/30/2011
AS I mentioned, TDK tops any film Marvel has ever produced, BUT...X2 does come a close second as far as superhero sequels are concerned. It took its source material seriously and the final act contained very few jokes and no "wink wink" moments to hurt it and try to "remind" us that it's based off of a comic; unlike movies that other hack companies have produced (*COUGH*MARVELSTUDIOS*COUGH*). One of the problems however was the rushed 'Mary Sue' progression of Jean Grey and the unnecessary, non-sensical sacrifice she made in the end, that and Magneto's switching of the plates in the fake Cerebro, which was really a "Style over substance" moment that made no sense. TDK just had a tighter script and better overall performances. In the list of films based on comics: 1. TDK 2. Batman Begins 3. X2.
on 4/8/2012
Dark Knight. Chris Nolan saved the Batman franchise with this film.
on 7/10/2012
Christopher Nolan redefined a genre.
on 11/5/2013
X men 2
on 3/23/2014
ratedvs overrated. Guess which one is which
on 3/25/2014
The Dark Knight for sure.
on 4/12/2016
Dark Knight.
on 10/12/2018
Dark Knight owns X2 in every way..
on 10/13/2018
Of all the first generation comic book films X2 is still the best. Holds up so well.
on 3/20/2021
Dark Knight is way better than any X-Men movies
on 3/13/2022
TDK wins but x2 is the third best CBM of the 2000s
on 11/20/2022
I like X2. I do. But there are individual scenes in TDK that solo the entirety of X2
