Sign In Now ►
or Create A New Account ►
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
Both films are in my top 20, but The Dark Knight cracks my top 5.
The Dark Knight sucks and it is TOO OVERRATED, Once Upon a Time in the West is the true classic winner here.
The West is probably the better movie (although it is hard to tell which one is better), but I prefer TDK out of these two masterpieces.
Really tough matchup. Going with Leone here.
Leone is one of the best when it comes to westerns but as a film I prefer The Dark Knight.
Two of the defining films of their respective decades, going with the Dark Knight.
I find OUATITW dull and forgettable. Dark Knight is the complete opposite because of the great acting and incredibly smart and well written script!
I have to go with The Dark Knight. Once Upon a Time in the West was always a little ponderous for my taste.
The Dark Knight is higher in my top
Once Upon a Time in the West beats overblown every time.