Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
15 comments
5 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/15/2010
X-men and its not even close
on 5/20/2010
"The Dark Knight" for me. It's over-rated, yes, but "X-Men" never did much for me (aside from some solid performances by Ian McKellan, Patrick Stewart and Hugh Jackman).
on 7/19/2010
I'm not one to kiss TDK's butt all over the place, but X-Men was bland as hell.
on 7/23/2010
I'm one to kiss TDK's butt all over the place. It's a far better film than X-Men (which I still enjoyed).
on 9/9/2010
Yep TDK is miles above any of the X-men movies, X-2 would give me pause, but not enough to go against it.
on 5/8/2012
While I give X-Men credit for being the best franchise starter of any Marvel product, toe to toe and pound for pound, it doesn't measure up to the "Empire Strikes Back" of graphic novel adaptations. The Dark Knight for the win.
The Dark Knight is clearly a superhero movie, but it transcends the genre so much it feels like it should be in an entirely different category than something like X-Men. It blows it totally out of the water.
on 6/28/2013
I realize I'm alone on this, but I like X-Men better.
The Dark Knight is my clear choice. It isn't just a great comic book movie, but a phenomenal flick on its own. X-Men is good (great even!) but nowhere near the same caliber as The Dark Knight
on 6/29/2013
Never been a huge X-Men fan. They are enjoyable, but The Dark Knight is better in every way.
on 12/11/2014
Dark Knight. X-Men is my favorite of the X-Men movies, but the Dark Knight continues to blow me away every time.
on 2/8/2015
The Dark Clown is best to first X-Men movie
Dark Knight is better to X-Men
on 2/28/2015
X-Men easily
on 6/25/2015
Dark Knight is more the T2 of comic book movies. Not Empire Strikes Back. Dark Knight beats X-Men
on 6/3/2017
X-Men lands higher, better and broke more ground.
on 6/4/2017
X-Men is quite meh. The Dark Knight is a great film.
on 8/17/2021
TDK beats logan, x1 is nothing
on 9/7/2022
I love X-Men, but not even X2 or Logan stands a chance.
on 12/8/2022
The Dark Knight is simply the best comic book movie ever made