Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
13 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/29/2009
Battle of the Foreigns! So now it's down to kooky love or solo hammer fighting, balls deep, action. I like lovvvvvvvvve ^-^
on 8/11/2009
Been awhile since I've seen either...and they're both great movies...but I think I like the whimsical style of Amélie better
on 11/16/2009
Not that Oldboy isn't great, but Amelie rules.
on 12/28/2009
mpff
on 2/28/2010
Amelie is cool and all, but Oldboy just a better film in all respects.
on 3/6/2010
Both great movies, but only one amazing soundtrack.
on 8/5/2010
Adorable quirky french romantic comedy vs. gritty quirky korean action flick. Amelie wins this one 'cause she's just so darn cute!
on 11/5/2010
Amelie is the definition of average IMO. "Hey look at me, I'm quirky, fluffy and cute so you have to like me even though I have little else to offer. Oldboy is comical and intense at the same time. And fucked up.
Amelie has a quirky charm but Oldboy was brilliant.
on 12/14/2010
These are so phenomenally different it's impossible to give either an edge.
on 12/15/2010
Arguing between these two is like arguing that home-made lasagna is better than monarchism; it doesn't even make sense. That said, Oldboy is better.
on 1/22/2011
Oldboy has that awesome hallway hammerfight scene, but Amelie overall was much more enjoyable
on 8/23/2011
Oldboy hands down. It's just a complete masterpiece in every conceivable way and Amelie simply can't compare.
on 10/7/2011
Close one to call... but Amelie for me... Oldboy was just too much headfk for me! :) in fact the whole Sympathy for whoever it is got too depressing for words... so Amelie for being cute and uplifting! :)
on 10/8/2011
Oldboy...so brutal...mindnumbing. Impossible to forget...
on 7/22/2012
Oldboy, easily the better movie, people go on about how enjoyable Amelie is, Oldboy isn't meant to be enjoyable it's meant to make you squirm
on 12/2/2012
These could not be more different. I'd have to go with Old Boy just because I've seen it more times, and the ending was so amazing. But Amelie reignited my passion for playing piano, I learned every piece from that movie that Yann T. Composed.
on 12/10/2014
Gotta be Amelie. Oldboy is great but very hard to rank. It's just so damn insane.
on 11/25/2015
Definitely Oldboy, I've never heard an arguement why Amelie would be better than just average.
on 4/20/2016
Oldboy by a landslide
on 1/18/2017
Oldboy, better in every way.
on 7/31/2017
Oldboy is an epic film, Amelie just makes my head hurt.
on 11/7/2017
amélie is great, but oldboy is incredible
