Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
7 comments
11 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 2/3/2010
One of the easier Pixar-offs. Monsters is one of the few Pixar flicks where I didn't connect with the characters all that much. Maybe it demands a rewatching, but right now, Up's got it.
on 2/26/2010
Well, Monsters, inc. is brilliant, funny and creative, but Up is, no pun intended, a cut above.
on 5/3/2010
Until I rewatch UP, my vote is for Monsters, Inc.
on 5/20/2010
"Up," hands down. I never quite got into "Monsters, Inc." which is uncommon for a Pixar story. I still feel like the anthropomorphic dogs were a bit much (at the least, incongruous with the emotional beginning of the film), but "Up" remains the most touching story they've told yet.
I like Monsters, Inc., but it is somewhat lacking in the heart of Pixar's other films. Sure, Boo's story can be touching, but not nearly as touching as Carl's story in Up. It's this emotional resonance that puts Up ahead of Monsters, Inc.
I was surprised at how 'not great' Up is. Still good of course but there are large spells of 'who gives a flying fuck at a rolling donut'.
on 5/24/2010
I love Monsters, Inc. Up is quite good, but nothing special. Easy choice.
on 6/14/2010
Really tough choice. But I have to go with Up. A little bit more original than Monster Inc.
on 2/13/2011
Two of my favorite Pixar films UP is great but I have to go with Monsters, Inc. here just because I found it a little more fun overall.
on 12/13/2011
Has an edge over Monsters Inc.
on 3/23/2012
damm!
on 8/19/2012
Monsters simply because I laughed when the old dude's WEIRD ASS WIFE DIED. Like out loud. In the theatre.
The more I watch Up...the further down my rankings it falls. Monsters Inc holds steady...
on 12/20/2012
Up. Monsters Inc. is great too, but even at a young age that girl made me pull my hairs out.
Monsters Inc hands down. Big part of my childhood.
on 12/21/2012
Monsters Inc. is one of Pixars best, Up is great as well just not quite as great.
on 2/11/2013
Up gave me the sense of adventure Monsters Inc. didn't give me. Make no mistake Monsters Inc. is still a favorite of mine.
on 3/5/2013
Monsters Inc is a movie that I can watch again and again
on 4/6/2013
Two excellent Pixar movies, but everything Monsters Inc. did, I feel Up did a bit better.
on 7/13/2015
Up by a hair
on 8/31/2015
nnonononononono
on 12/8/2015
I love both of those (as well as most of Pixar), but Monsters, Inc. has some little off-moments. Up, on the other hand, is easily a 10-star movie - I love pretty much every minute of it. Up wins.
on 3/2/2021
Up had an amazing first 10 minutes, but it was an average movie for the rest of it. Monsters Inc is perfect the whole way through
