A Charlie Brown Christmas vs. How the Grinch Stole Christmas!



on 12/7/2009

Two holiday classics... I have to go with Charlie Brown though... "Christmas Time Is Here" with Guaraldi on piano is just a beautiful song.

on 12/10/2009

How do you choose? These are both essential holiday classics!

on 1/24/2010

Each one of these is, most definitely, essential holiday viewing. Charlie Brown is just nearer and dearer to my heart than Dr. Seuss.

on 4/6/2010

Crap!! Really?? These two are so awesome?' Not fair!

on 10/31/2010

The Charlie Brown movies never really did much for me. They weren't bad by any means, but How the Grinch Stole Christmas was just a classic, yearly tradition around Christmas for me.

on 11/23/2010

A tough one, two great Christmas Classics here while I love the Grinch I have to go with Charlie Brown here I mean come on like it says on the poster it's a Peanuts classic and thats hard to beat.

on 8/30/2012

The two seminal tv Christmas classics! They're both fantastic, of course, but Charlie Brown is more to my sensibilities. The sadness and depression of a holiday, the ultimate redemption of friends and love.

on 8/30/2012

Chuck Brown for the win...

on 3/31/2014

Both great animated short film classics

on 4/1/2014

Charlie Brown wins for me.

on 4/10/2014

Oo wow both really close but I think I have to take Charlie Brown's side on this

on 3/5/2015

Good matchup, but gotta go with Charlie Brown.

on 2/12/2018

Both classics, and still love 'em.

on 2/6/2019

Both Christmas classics, not much between them. I give the edge to Charlie Brown on the strength of Vince Guaraldi's music.