The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King vs. The Dark Knight

26 comments

19 comments

This is an extremely hard one...i almost want to quit my browser and forget this even happened to me...

This is unfair. I dunno what to do.

Return of the King has the momentum of the first two films and ends them perfectly. The Dark Knight is great but doesn't have the weight that the entire Lord of the Rings franchise carries with it. Yet.

Ouch! This hurts...

Wow. One of the hardest matchups for me. I have to agree with dallas on this one.

Okay, collectively, I prefer The Lord of the Rings. But I think TDK is better than the final chapter. My top two films are The Fellowship of the Ring, and The Dark Knight, in that order. And really, the main reason I prefer both to The Return of the King is because of the ending(s). I agree with Jack Nicholson: "Too many endings, man...." Not too many for the 12-hour epic that the extended versions are, but it was too much in the theater. TDK edges out ROTK for me.

Well now, let's see. Hold a nail in one hand, and a box of nails in the other. Which one serves you better? Feeble analogy I know, but it's next to impossible to objectively compare these two very different movies. While both movies nailed it, RoTK nailed it over and over and over. That's all I'm sayin'.

Both of these are uber-solemn pulp fantasies. I like ROTK more.

ROTK has swords and Howard Shore on its side. That barely edges it out for me.

LOTR. All three are better than The Dark Knight.

Freakishly difficult choice as I've always regarded both films as the best in my list of watched movies. Have to go with LOTR just because it's the ending of the trilogy, so the impact is greater. Compared on other aspects, they both equal.

Two amazing films, both of which lose me at the end (for different reasons).

Return of the king is an epic adventure and has a great story but come on, The Joker is arguably the greatest villain of all time and Ledger pulls off one of the greatest performances ever.

JRM
JRM

The Dark Knight always wins . . . almost always wins. But it wins this one.

both movies are beyond phenomenal and some of my favorites all-time. but Batman wins by a very small margin.

Both are outstanding movies. Looked at individually, I might be inclined to vote for The Dark Knight, But if you view it as a whole, Lord of the Rings is, I think, better. So with that in mind, I'm voting for Return of the King.

Heath Ledger is incredible, and Nolan directs a mean film, but Return of the King is, for me, a perfect film.

ROTK of finishes up an amazing trilogy with the film of them all. The Dark Knight is an amazing piece of film making that will stand the test time, but ROTK is just a step above.

The Return of the King is one of the most ovverated movies ever and its TOO boring, The Dark Knight beats The Return of the King anytime.

The Dark Knight for now.

The Dark Knight it is.

LOTR IS LEGEND!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Return of the King

Damn that's a tough choice. These are probably my first and second favourite movies of all time. Return of the King will have to win for me though, I'm a bigger fan of Lord of the Rings in general than I am of Batman.

Lord of the Rings rules all except Star Wars

I must give it to The Dark Knight. Now if it were Batman Begins vs. ROTK, it would to the ROTK.

Return of the King easy for me

The Dark Knight has Batman and Hans Zimmer. Edge goes to Nolan

I just watched both trilogies in the last week. They are my two favorite trilogies of all time (Star Wars is a close third). They currently stand at 4 and 5 on my chart. The Dark Knight has the very slight edge.

@Connerwood1998- Don't forget, LOTR has Howard Shore!!!

Epic matchup! The best of the LOTR trilogy vs. the best of the DK trilogy. The best fantasy movie ever vs. the best comic book adaptation ever. TDK is certainly a worthy opponent, but in the end, ROTK is just about unbeatable in my book. There are only about 5 movies that I can think of that I enjoyed as much or more that ROTK, and TDK isn't one of them. ROTK wins.

TDK by a longshot.

The Dark Knight. Very close.

... Return of the King is my favorite of these two

think dark knight for now. Heath ledger owned much of the movie itself

RotK

Well you watch one David Lean film and Return of the King pales in comparison. It's depressing but I feel the Dark Knight is superior of the 2. But that's not to say that Return of the King is bad in any way.

Have to go with LOTR

I prefer the dark knight

Return of the King

Two master cinematic opuses that redefined film for the 21st century. Both are ABSOLUTE required viewing for anyone with even a modicum of good taste. Dark Knight for this battle.

What madness is this?

Lord of the Rings, not even close

The Dark Knight is just overrated movie

Aragorn is even more powerful than Batman. He is a legendary hero in the novel.

Dark Knight is much a convenient film, RotK is long boring film ever...

ear
ear

Return of The King has too many endings to win this. I loved them both.

Return of the King by miles.