Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
14 comments
10 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 9/26/2011
Wow, super tough. Two superbly written films, I think I have to go with Fargo for the better acting though.
on 12/4/2011
You see... and now... with the... GAH!
Fargo for me. Memento was spoiled for me, so it didn't have the same impact as it should of.
on 2/8/2012
I've never been as big a Memento fan as my male peers. They cannot get enough of it! Fargo for me, was a revelation in cinema, it told me " Yes, there is incredible independent cinema out there in the English language". Thank God for the Coens.
on 6/18/2012
Memento
on 11/5/2012
Memento for sure. The plot was more advanced and kept you on the edge.
on 5/25/2013
This one is all Memento.
on 7/28/2013
I liked Memento, but it loses its appeal with multiple viewings. Fargo takes this.
Every Coen brothers film is much better than every Nolan film.
Must go Memento....but it's two movies I love....
on 8/27/2013
Memento is just too good.
Both of these films have a great plot, but Memento wins.
on 3/20/2014
Fargo.
on 4/10/2014
Hard one Fargo for now have to rewatch Memento
on 6/26/2014
Fargo
on 9/6/2014
one diminishes with each viewing, while the other thrives off of each viewing. fargo.
on 9/8/2014
Memento crushes Fargo in my opinion.
on 9/9/2014
Two fabulous films. Memento wins easily here, but love both
on 8/25/2015
Both great but Memento keeps you thinking even after the movie's finished.
on 8/16/2016
Frances McDormand wins it with how she crosses the pregnant "oh golly gee" wife with the cop who catches the guy at the wood chipper
on 5/2/2017
Fargo by a very slim margin.
on 5/18/2019
It's tough but Memento for me
on 10/14/2019
on 1/10/2020
I like both a lot. Memento is my favorite Christopher Nolan film though so I'm going with it.
on 10/8/2022
Fargo because it's faster paced.
on 3/1/2023
Fargo is probably better but Memento is just something special
