The Thin Red Line vs. Pan's Labyrinth

5 comments

1 comments

Very hard choice

The Thin Red Line by a long shot. Pan's Labyrinth is a well-made film, but isn't the masterpiece that many hailed it as upon release.

Indeed very hard. Maybe when I re-watch The Thin Red Line, the decision could change. But for now, I'm going with Pan's Labyrinth.

Pans labyrinth is more of my type of film Thin Red Line is Good but only barely top 20 war film good unless you watch the uncut directors version which is hard to find! while PAN is beautifully raw and vicious with depth and magic.

Thin Red Line in a close, close call...

Pan's Labyrinth, but like everyone said, extremely close.