Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/7/2009
two amazing movies based on comic books, I'm still feel the buzz of The Dark Knight and Heath Ledger's amazing performance, so I'm giving the nod to The Dark Knight!
on 11/24/2009
Superman was a tighter movie. For all of the talk about Heath Ledger's performance, there's still the rest of the film (especially the second half) that was tedious.
on 6/15/2012
Both are arguably the greatest films of the superhero/ comic inspired genre, with each take complamenting the hero it protrays. While Superman is more visually imressive and has the more iconic score, while The Dark Knight features better performances and a better script. It can go either way for me, but for now The Dark Knight wins.
Dark Knight: Better supporting cast and villain and tighter plot Superman: Better main protagonist. Dark Knight wins.
on 6/30/2013
This matchup shouldn't be taken too lightly. TDK still wins.
on 12/12/2013
Got stay with Superman
on 1/16/2014
What's so great about the Superman movie? Dark Knight wins without hesitation.
on 11/23/2017
Give me the effortless magic of Christopher Reeve and Donner's Superman over the ponderous self-seriousness of The Dark Knight
on 11/24/2017
Love both... but The Dark Knight for being more filmic I guess!
on 10/5/2020
The Dark Knight for sure. Superman is still great, but The Dark Knight is on a completely different level.
on 12/15/2020
Allow me to break the tie. I think Superman is the greatest superhero film ever. Maybe the Dark Knight has a better third act, but nothing tops the magic of Superman.
on 1/7/2021
Superman isn't even the best Superman movie (that belongs to Superman II)
on 4/5/2022
Two classics and all, but the best Batman movie tops the best Superman movie anyday
