Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
12 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/28/2009
This one basically boils down to, "Do I want my aliens fighting or loving?"
on 8/31/2009
Whoa! The epitome of the finest movies ever created! How do you rate them? Sadness or action? ACTION!! ALL THE WAY! Star Wars, baby!
on 5/3/2010
Hmm. I'm going with ET.
on 6/1/2012
E.T., but they're both wonderful films.
on 8/7/2012
I love both, but I'm going to have to go with Star Wars. Star Wars doesn't make me cry.
on 10/15/2013
Star Wars wins easily despite ET being a very good film.
Star Wars. No question.
on 10/19/2013
E.T easily for now though Star Wars is a top 20 film, E.T is a top 3 for me
on 11/12/2013
Star wars is more entertaining and better made overal more rewatchable and better
on 7/1/2015
After 5 minutes thinking, I have to say "Star Wars", but not by much. I love these family blockbuster Spielberg films, and E.T. is a loving story I love since when I'm about 7/8 years old. It's a simple story, and beats "Empire Strikes Back". But, my nostalgia feelings has to opt for the more interesting and complex story. "Star Wars" wins!
on 9/27/2015
Before saying it's better, gotta re watch E.T...
E.T. the extraterrestrial
on 10/29/2015
Sorry, E.T....but it's Star Wars.
on 11/23/2015
Star Wars is a 9-star film. E.T. is a 10-star film. E.T. wins.
on 4/17/2017
Why. Why... Why.
on 11/27/2017
These two films are the definition of "Movie Magic". Both are timeless masterpieces. It's a tie, but I don't think Star Wars needs any help from me. I'll vote ET.
on 11/28/2017
i think both of these movies boil down to personal love, which i don't have much of for either. i guess i prefer star wars
on 6/17/2018
et
on 5/28/2019
ET is no match any of Star Wars, Star Wars easily wins here.
on 11/30/2019
Most for sure Star Wars destroys any alien.
on 9/27/2020
Two great classics but Star wars wins.