E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial vs. Star Wars

6 comments

12 comments

This one basically boils down to, "Do I want my aliens fighting or loving?"

Whoa! The epitome of the finest movies ever created! How do you rate them? Sadness or action? ACTION!! ALL THE WAY! Star Wars, baby!

JRM
JRM

Hmm. I'm going with ET.

E.T., but they're both wonderful films.

I love both, but I'm going to have to go with Star Wars. Star Wars doesn't make me cry.

Star Wars wins easily despite ET being a very good film.

Star Wars. No question.

E.T easily for now though Star Wars is a top 20 film, E.T is a top 3 for me

Star wars is more entertaining and better made overal more rewatchable and better

After 5 minutes thinking, I have to say "Star Wars", but not by much. I love these family blockbuster Spielberg films, and E.T. is a loving story I love since when I'm about 7/8 years old. It's a simple story, and beats "Empire Strikes Back". But, my nostalgia feelings has to opt for the more interesting and complex story. "Star Wars" wins!

Before saying it's better, gotta re watch E.T...

E.T. the extraterrestrial

Sorry, E.T....but it's Star Wars.

Star Wars is a 9-star film. E.T. is a 10-star film. E.T. wins.

Why. Why... Why.

These two films are the definition of "Movie Magic". Both are timeless masterpieces. It's a tie, but I don't think Star Wars needs any help from me. I'll vote ET.

i think both of these movies boil down to personal love, which i don't have much of for either. i guess i prefer star wars

et

ET is no match any of Star Wars, Star Wars easily wins here.

Most for sure Star Wars destroys any alien.

Two great classics but Star wars wins.