Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
7 comments
2 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/8/2011
No one has commented on this yet? Really? In any event, it's got to be "The Seventh Seal" for me. I admire "8 1/2" but I fell in love with "The Seventh Seal."
on 9/30/2011
Since commenting 206 days ago, I've actually discovered "8 1/2" has gotten under my skin recently and really resonated with me on a very personal level. Still, "The Seventh Seal" continues to win this match.
on 5/27/2013
Oh, how times change! "8 1/2" has now become much dearer to me than "The Seventh Seal". I connected with it on a very personal level, whereas I find my enjoyment and admiration of "The Seventh Seal" is more of an artistic nature.
on 7/23/2013
This is one of those matchups where I don't know whether to vote for my favorite or the one I think is better. Usually there isn't a difference with me, but in this case there is. 8 1/2 is better, but I prefer The Seventh Seal. I guess I'll vote my heart, because re-watchability has to mean something.
on 8/13/2013
8 1/2 is not by any stretch of the imagination better than the The Seventh Seal. The Seventh Seal is VASTLY SUPERIOR.
on 9/20/2014
I actually find The Seventh Seal really entertaining
on 10/25/2014
I prefer like six or seven Bergman films over The Seventh Seal. 8 1/2 is a genius roller-coaster of bizarre amazement. It's like Fellini vomited on a wall and then painted over it. No other film delves into the creative mind quite like this one.
Seventh Seal
on 12/14/2014
Sticking with 8½ this time, but it's not as though I've got anything bad to say about THE SEVENTH SEAL. I feel closer to a few other Bergman films these days, though (PERSONA and SAWDUST & TINSEL).
on 11/9/2017
i love both, but 8 1/2 is in my top 20
on 5/26/2019
Seventh Seal for me.
