Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
3 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/1/2012
Both have Baby i the title, but they are complete polar opposites, they both are great 10/10 films but I gotta go with Rosemarys Baby
Bringing up Baby is a grade-A comedy with sharp, well-delivered lines and a fun story. Rosemary's Baby is terrific in its playfully dark tone and its fantastic leading performance. The Polanski wins out for me.
Rosemary's Baby....literally....by murder.
on 7/5/2013
Bringing Up Baby was underwhelming for me. I really like both Grant and Hepburn, but the laughs were few and far between. Rosemary's Baby, no question.
on 7/6/2013
I didn't much like either, but I suppose Bringing Up Baby bored me less...
on 3/24/2015
Im a huge Cary Grant fan and Bringing Up Baby is sharp funny and sweet but not a fav of mine While Rosemary's Baby Is scary terrific dark and has crazy ideas and characters! not a favorite Horror film but I like it more each time I watch it when im in the mood! the Big Baby winner here is Polanski!
on 1/16/2018
love polanski's baby more than hawks'
on 6/27/2018
Love both but I'm actually going to go with "Bringing Up Baby". Cary Grant, in particular, is just such a laugh riot for me in that film and it's just my kind of humour. I recently saw Bogdanovich's "What's Up, Doc?" which in many ways was a soft remake of Bringing Up Baby and as much as I liked it, I was reminded of how much I love Bringing Up Baby. I can see my decision changing in the future but for now, the dynamic of the delightfully irritable Hepburn and the naive and clumsy Grant wins out for me.
Rosemary's Baby>Bringing Up Baby
